This is article number 64.
Total number of articles in current database is 93.
For a listing of all previously posted articles please visit our ICFDA Archives.


8/2/2004

Zoloft: grieving parents mourn

http://www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/news/local/9299841.htm?ERIGHTS=-5287220694205161873philly

Phiiadelphia Inquirer

Below is the article I just mentioned in the last e-mail from the Philadelphia Inquirer. This will explain what happened to cause the postponing of the Congressional Hearing on Antidepressants that was supposed to happen July 20, 2004.

And I would like to make a comment about the following statement by Greenwood:

"Besides, he added, the hearing was merely postponed until after the August recess. In tomorrow's column, I will let Greenwood explain in detail."

What he left out here is what a very advantageous move this was by the pharmaceutical companies. These antidepressants bring in about $100 million per day. Multiply about 51 days by $100 Million and subtract the $650,000 they will pay Greenwood as his start up pay and you see what an incredible investment this was for them. So Greenwood should not be allowed to get away with a statement like this to appease us.

As for me I concur fully with our PA directors, Tom and Kathy Woodward. They have stated my feelings on this from the minute I heard on July 18 in Washington, DC while awaiting the hearing: "As for the Woodwards, they believe every day Congress delays is a day another Julie could end up dead."

Thank you Tom and Kathy for an excellent article. Thank you for sharing your pain so that others will not have to go through what you have.

Once again I ask as I have so many times in the past decade and a half, "How many more innocent victims do we allow to die before we do something about this drug-induced nightmare?"

Ann Blake Tracy, Ph.D.

The garage where Julie Woodward took her life is gone now, bulldozed by her grieving parents, as though that could erase what happened there.

Just over a year ago, on July 22, 2003, the 17-year-old North Penn High School junior hanged herself in the garage behind the family's house in North Wales. Her father found her body the next morning.

No parent can understand a child's suicide, but Julie's death was particularly puzzling. A bookworm who studied Latin, Julie had always been cautious and reserved and never impulsive. "She had no history whatsoever of self-harm or suicide," her father, Tom Woodward, said last week.

Julie was planning to leave on a college-hunting trip with her family later that week. In her journal, found after her death, she dreamed of a happy future of marriage and babies.

"She was just a very bright, self-preserving kid," her mother, Kathy, said.

What could lead such a child to kill herself? The day after Julie's death, the Woodwards got a possible clue. Their neighbor, North Wales Mayor Douglas Ross, shared information he had spent the night gleaning off the Internet. It linked a class of antidepressant drugs known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) with suicidal impulses in children.

A difficult transition

Julie, a pretty girl with sand-blonde hair that fell to her shoulders, had been not only a child model but, as her parents describe her, a model child.

But the year before her death, she transferred from a small all-girls school to sprawling North Penn High, where she struggled to fit in. She became unhappy, withdrawn and irritable. Her parents took her to a psychiatrist, who diagnosed depression and prescribed the antidepressant Zoloft.

Tom Woodward said doctors assured him that Zoloft was "mild, very safe, and essential to her treatment."

Seven days after she began the medication, Julie killed herself. Her parents are convinced there's a link. "If Julie had never taken Zoloft, she would be alive today," Tom Woodward said. "I am 100 percent sure of that."

They found a champion in U.S. Rep. James Greenwood, a Bucks County Republican and longtime children's advocate. As chairman of the subcommittee on oversight and investigations, Greenwood had led high-profile probes into Enron, Martha Stewart and human cloning.

Six months after Julie's death, Greenwood announced that his committee would investigate the link between antidepressants and youth suicide.

The hearing was scheduled for July 20, and the Woodwards planned to attend. "We were looking at this as a watershed moment," Tom Woodward said.

An abrupt change of plans

But the day before the hearing, Greenwood informed the Woodwards that the hearing was being postponed for unspecified reasons.

Only later would they learn that, a few days earlier, Greenwood had quietly decided to leave Congress to accept a $650,000-a-year job - that's more than four times his congressional salary - as president of the Biotechnology Industry Organization, a trade group that represents numerous pharmaceutical companies, including Pfizer, maker of Zoloft, the drug Julie took before her death. A Pfizer vice president serves on the group's 46-member board of directors, which selected Greenwood.

The Woodwards felt betrayed and called the job offer on the eve of the hearing "very suspicious."

In a telephone conversation with Greenwood on the anniversary of Julie's death, Kathy Woodward accused Greenwood of allowing the pharmaceutical industry to buy his silence. "I think he sold out all the victims and future victims," she said.

Greenwood, in a 90-minute interview with me Friday, strongly denied any nefarious undertones to his new career choice. He defended his actions as ethical and said the Woodwards' accusations are based on a groundless conspiracy theory that began circulating on the Internet after he announced his new job.

Besides, he added, the hearing was merely postponed until after the August recess. In tomorrow's column, I will let Greenwood explain in detail.

As for the Woodwards, they believe every day Congress delays is a day another Julie could end up dead.